Monday 23 July 2018

Zanu PF is rigging these elections, worst you can is legitimise it by participating - Yatsvika musheche yamwa! N Garikai


“Collective active boycott is not the end of political activism, but the beginning of a political engagement to revolutionise and democratise the electoral college in Zimbabwe. The calling is not for people to do nothing. The only thing necessary for the triumph over evil is for the good men and women to do nothing, (Burke E). Collective and organised boycott is doing something. It is a call to organize, not a call for inaction,” wrote Themba Mthethwa in Bulawayo 24.

“By continuing to vote in flawed and blemished elections, we are not only refusing to make an ideological breakaway from electoral exploitation, extortion and oppression. Doing nothing is promoting and validating a system that has constantly violated our human right to vote within the framework of freedom, tranquillity, openness, transparency, equality, fairness, and credibility.

“We own the vote. It is our vote. We must trade it at best value, best service and for good returns. It is our vital currency for bargaining in return for issues that resonate with our wellbeing, emotions, aspirations, hope, wants and needs. Let us put forward the question of what kind of democracy and society we want.

Thank you, Themba, for making sure there is not a single Zimbabwean out there who can ever say he/she did not know Zanu PF is rigging these elections and the folly of taking part in the sham elections!

What many people have failed to understand here is that Zanu PF is investing a lot of time and resources in making sure the opposition does not boycott these elections regardless how flawed and illegal the process gets. During national harmonised elections, not so with by-elections, Zanu PF has seen to it that the opposition win a few seats, hence the reason MDC have boycotted the later but always took part in the former.

"The worst aspect for me about the failure to agree a coalition was that both MDCs couldn't now do the obvious - withdraw from the (2013) elections," admitted David Coltart, former MDC senator and minister in the GNU, in his recent book.

"The electoral process was so flawed, so illegal, that the only logical step was to withdraw, which would compel SADC to hold Zanu PF to account. But such was the distrust between the MDC-T and MDC-N that neither could withdraw for fear that the other would remain in the elections, winning seats and giving the process credibility."

The opposition have pointedly refused to admit they are participating in these flawed elections out of greed (Coltart must have agonised over this when he put it is his book and, ever since, has avoided saying another word on the matter). They have dragged their naïve and gullible supporters into these flawed elections by repeatedly assuring them the elections were free, fair and credible or that they, the opposition, have devised “stringent measures to stop Zanu PF rigging the elections,” as Chamisa has been claiming.

Zanu PF has poured tonnes of money paying double agents whose primary purpose has been to convince the opposition supporters and the public that the opposition can win rigged elections and therefore it would be madness to boycott elections! In fact it is the exact opposite; it is insane to keep participating in flawed elections, 38 years and counting, hoping for a different result!

David Coltart is right to say by participating in these flawed elections, the opposition and ordinary voters alike, are giving the flawed process credibility and forfeiting the opportunity to demand the implementation of the democratic reforms.

How can these elections be free, fair and credible when ZEC has failed to produce a credible, clean and verified voters’ roll?

How can anyone agree to take part in an election process in which they know that many people who should be voting will be denied a vote and only God knows how many multiple votes those hooded Zanu PF youths will cast on Monday!

No Zimbabwean out there can ever say they did not know that Zanu PF is blatantly rigging these elections. By high noon next Monday the nation will once again have its nose rubbed raw with all the evidence of blatant vote rigging.

No doubt, Nelson Chamisa and all the opposition politicians will screaming from the rooftop, “Zanu PF stole the elections!” But the world will ignore them all, because the world has warned Zimbabweans 100 000 times and 100 000 times again that with no reforms Zanu PF will rig the vote and they refused to listen.

These elections should not be taking place without the reforms. By taking in part in the process, be it attending rallies or queuing to vote (whether you do or not is irrelevant) you are endorsing it. “Yatsvika musheche, yamwa!” (If the cow has sand on its hove then it drank!) as one would say in Shona.

But better still, do not just boycott these flawed and illegal elections; make sure everyone knows that you are boycotting and why. Make sure that the international election observers in Zimbabwe know you did not agree to the holding of these elections without first implementing the reforms and that you want the observers to declared these elections null and void!

So, to paraphrase E Burke; “The only thing necessary for Zanu PF to rig these elections and get away with it, is for the good men and women to boycott the elections and say nothing but, worst of all, for them to participate and thus give the flawed process credibility and legitimacy!”

11 comments:

  1. @ Themba

    When you are not even allowed to know who is on the voters' roll, have no idea who votes and how many times they are allowed to vote, etc. it is insane to take part in such a blatantly flawed and illegal process!

    ReplyDelete
  2. The MDC Alliance, have threatened to camp outside the ZEC offices in Harare to push for the implementation of key electoral reforms as well as transparency in the printing and distribution of ballot papers.

    "MDC has stringent measures to stop Zanu PF rigging the elections!" Nelson Chamisa has said again and again.

    What is clear now is that he was lying, MDC did not have a clue what to do to stop Zanu PF rigging elections. The party has been advised not to take part in these elections without first making sure the democratic reforms agreed at the onset of the GNU were implemented. They would not listen.

    Indeed, MDC leaders had five years during the GNU to implement these reforms but failed to get even one reform implemented.

    These elections should not have taken place with no reforms in place. It is all MDC's fault that we are in this mess! The night vigils are just another act of desperation on the part of the MDC; no one can serious expect any reforms to be implemented at this point just days before voting day!

    Zanu PF IS rigging these elections and any Zimbabwean out there with half a brain must now accept this reality. They must also accept that by participating in this sham election process, be it by attending rallies, MDC's meaningless vigil or joining the queue of voters on 30 July they are giving the flawed process credibility and legitimacy.

    What Zimbabwe needs right now is citizens with the common sense to finally admit that after 38 years of rigged elections it is insane to keep taking part in such elections and hoping against hope that Zanu PF will rig the vote and, somehow, lose the elections. We are stuck in this hell-hole precisely because we have not had the honour of having a significant segment of our people make that quantum intellectual leap!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Paul Mangwana: "MDC Alliance cannot hold Zimbabwe at ransom. They don't own Zimbabwe. They are a voluntary organisation which exists on the basis of volition. If they decide that they will not participate in the elections, it's their choice, but we will continue with the elections."

    Well that is rich coming from a party that has denied the people of Zimbabwe their freedoms and basic human rights including the right to free, fair and credible elections. Zanu PF wants the elections to go ahead and yet they cannot deny that there is no credible, clean and verified voters' roll.

    The biggest blunder MDC leaders have made was to fail to implement the democratic reforms designed to dismantle the Zanu PF dictatorship during the GNU. MDC leaders have only made the situation worse by agreeing to participate in these flawed elections against the advice of SADC leaders and many others.

    Walking out of these flawed elections will certainly be the most sensible think these MDC leaders have ever done in the party's 20 years existence.

    Zimbabweans themselves must walk out and refuse to take any part in these flawed and illegal elections; that would be the smartest thing they have ever done! It is insane taking part in rigged elections after 38 years of being cheated hoping for a different result!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Many hundreds of thousands of men, women and children have paid the ultimate price mortals pay in the search of freedom, justice and liberty before independence. Sadly many more hundreds of thousands of men, women and children have too paid the ultimate price still in search of the same things freedom, justice and liberty because those who rule the nation after independence short changed the many.

    To accept these flawed and illegal elections, this insult to natural justice, to humanity and to the the heavens above, as free, fair and credible elections is the most dishonourable thing any one of us can do right now. Whilst others have sacrificed their very lives so we can live in freedoms and liberty the very least we can do is to say what Zanu PF is offering us is NOT what they died for!

    How can these be democratic, free, fair and credible elections when the filthy rich ruling elite have the veto and the impoverished majority have but a token vote at best?

    How can it be possible that in this day and age that some people can still be so shallow, thick and slow they still do not know what constitute free, fair and credible elections even when it is their own freedom, justice, liberty and even their very lives at stake!

    The black majority were denied a vote by the white before independence. After independence we thought we finally had a vote only to realise that others had granted themselves a veto. We have waited for the right to a meaningful vote all our lives.

    It is bad enough that millions of ordinary Zimbabweans are yet to exercise the right to free, fair and credible elections but only a fool will accept this mockery for free and fair elections. We want gold and no more of the fools' gold!

    I agree all those who take part in these rigged elections are either first-class fools who do not know what is in their own interest or are paid stooges of the ruling elite or the ruling elite themselves! It is insane to keep giving legitimacy to and illegitimate act!

    ReplyDelete
  5. @ Joel Maweni

    "Not participating is simply handing over the election and our future. Zanu will not flinch and continue to shamelessly lording it over us for the next 5 without any flicker of opposition in parliament. They will have unfettered power to change the constitution. When the going gets tough the tough gets going. Boycotting is the answer to Zanu PF's prayers," you say.

    This is a fallacious argument and, like all fallacious arguments, it is based of foolish notion. You are assuming that by participating we get something but have not named what that something is because there is nothing we have gained. We have been stuck with a corrupt and tyrannical regime these last 38 years and with each passing year we have become poorer and poorer materially and politically as the repression has got progressively worse.

    If we are serious about living in a country where there is freedom, justice, liberty, human dignity for all and not just the few filthy rich ruling elite then we establish the rules, the laws and the constitution - the rule of law. One of the pillars of a society where there is rule of law is that no one is above the law.

    We are talking about these elections being free, fair and credible one of the essential requirement for free and fair elections is that there should be a credible, clean and verified voters' roll. President Mnangagwa has promised to hold free, fair and credible elections and unless he is also saying he is above the law them he must accept there must be a clean and verified voters' roll.

    If President Mnangagwa wants to rig these elections, just as Zanu PF has done countless times in the past then he should just do so and not pretend these are free and fair elections. If you want to participate in these flawed elections then you too must not pretend these are free and fair elections.

    After last November's military coup President Mnangagwa and his junta have two prayers they are hoping will be answered:

    1) That Zanu PF retains absolute power and to be absolutely certain of winning they have decided to rig the elections.

    2) They know that the world is sick to their back teeth of tyrants who rig elections to stay in power - after 37 years of Mugabe, Mnangagwa and company know Zanu PF is certainly of such tyrannical regime - and so they are pulling all the stops to create the illusion these elections are free, fair and credible. Making sure that the opposition and voters participate is one of the basic requirement for this smoke screen to work. Zanu PF is helping the opposition including MDC, directly and indirectly, to make sure they do not boycott these elections because its legitimacy dependence on credible electoral process.

    "Boycotting is the answer to Zanu PF's prayers!" You could not be more wrong!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Artur Jovo

    "We want to see how Mr Mnangagwa is going to rig these Elections."

    So you still do not see that with no credible, clean and verified voters' roll Zanu PF will employ all manner of vote rigging shenanigans such as making many voters turn up at the wrong polling stations and thus deny them a vote? Well, it is not everyone who see and perceive, hear and understand. But then there are those who see and perceive and hear and understand but pretend not to perceive and to understand to deceive! I will let the readers judge which side you belong to for themselves!

    Yes everything will come to an end but not by doing the same foolish thing over and over again. We are not going to end Zanu PF tyrannical rule by participating and legitimising the regime's vote rigging!

    You stop the madness of rigged elections by demanding the implementation of reforms BEFORE elections! If people participate in these flawed elections then by this time next week they will be regretting doing so but too late!

    ReplyDelete
  7. @ Bheveni Sibanda

    "It's unfortunate they are 23 candidates in this election saka MDC ikaramba it means ED anoramba achingotonga zvisina mheremhere. kupinda kana kusapinda muma election ED arikuzvambaradza vanhu."

    These elections are not free, fair and credible because there is no free public press; no credible, clean and verified voters' roll; etc. People should not participate in these flawed elections because they will only give legitimacy to the process. Whether there are two contestants, 23 or 2 000 that is totally irrelevant!

    ReplyDelete
  8. @ Joel Maweni

    "Wilbert Mukori kana yasvika ku foolish notions we can say nothing but say thanks boss. However, I still maintain that at the moment the greatest gift to the Zany party is a boycott. Quitters never win. But yave ne foolish notions saka taibuda."

    Elections are like every other contest, before the contest it is important to establish the rules of the contest. In this case we accept that there must be one-person one-vote and the voters' must be listed in credible, clean and verified voters' roll. The body, ZEC, entrusted to produce the verified voters' roll at least one month before nomination day has failed to produce one.

    It is impossible to see how these elections can be free, fair and credible if there is no credible, clean and verified voters' roll. Rules are there for the purpose of protecting the weak and those who up hold the law from the powerful and lawless. If the rules are being broken you stand up to the those breaking the rules and tell them straight that no one is above the rules. You do not spit on the sidewalk, curse in the dark and wish for the best.

    If you think Chamisa and company are contest these flawed and illegal elections because they are not "quitters" then you really are naïve and gullible.

    "The worst aspect for me about the failure to agree a coalition was that both MDCs couldn't now do the obvious - withdraw from the (2013) elections," confessed David Coltart, in the quotation in the article.

    "The electoral process was so flawed, so illegal, that the only logical step was to withdraw, which would compel SADC to hold Zanu PF to account. But such was the distrust between the MDC-T and MDC-N that neither could withdraw for fear that the other would remain in the elections, winning seats and giving the process credibility."

    You heard it from the horse's own mouth, MDC leaders are participating in these flawed elections out of greed, G.R.E.E.D, GREED!

    It is the ordinary people who have paid dearly for this madness of rigged elections. Of course, it is very tragic that these MDC leaders are taking advantage of green horn like you who cannot see they are being exploited even after the confession of one of these corrupt and incompetent opportunist is read to them!

    ReplyDelete
  9. @ R Mujuru

    There are some people who are satisfied with simple explanations.

    So when Chamisa devotees explain that the growing partnership between Nelson Chamisa and Jonathan Moyo, and his sidekick Edmund Kudzayi, is based on these G40 diehards suddenly seeing the light of Nelson Chamisa, it is enough for them.

    For many of us however, such overly simplistic explanations won't cut it.

    Why is it that people like Moyo and Kudzayi who fought tooth and nail against the MDC, using the most disgraceful tactics, are now actively campaigning for Chamisa?

    And why is it that these men that do not know the meaning of the word democracy are now fighting against ED's new dispensation - recognised by all international observers as a drastic improvement on anything Zimbabwe has previously experienced - for not being democratic enough?

    Everything you said made sense until: "And why is it that these men that do not know the meaning of the word democracy are now fighting against ED's new dispensation - recognised by all international observers as a drastic improvement on anything Zimbabwe has previously experienced - for not being democratic enough?"

    Yes ED loves talking about the "new dispensation" as is it is something new; it is not. Zanu PF, before last November's military coup, was a party of corrupt, vote-rigging and murderous thugs. The coup removed is old figure head and a few others around him but the majority of the corrupt, vote-rigging and murderous thugs led by Mugabe's chief enforcer, Emmerson Mnangagwa, has remained. The Zanu PF dictatorship is alive and thriving under new management.

    President Mnangagwa has refused to implement even one democratic reforms and is rigging these elections just as the party has rigged elections in the past. So, all talk of "drastic improvements" in Zimbabwe is pure propaganda!

    ReplyDelete
  10. @ Joel Maweni

    "Hupenzi inyama yegakava!" (The insane are stubbornly insane!) as my late mother would say!

    "If MDC boycotts Zanu rides to a historic win. That is all I can see at the moment. They will smile all the way to the bank," you say.

    With not even one democratic reform in place and clearly none of "MDC's stringent measures to stop Zanu PF rigging the elections" have had any effect; it is as clear as day that Zanu PF is rigging these elections. Zanu PF is winning these elections regardless of whether MDC boycotted the elections or not. The only reason why Zanu PF does NOT want MDC and the public to boycott the elections is to do with giving the rigged elections legitimacy!

    "If MDC boycotts a lot of people (definitely excluding you) will be disappointed as they have been waiting for this moment however futile an exercise others might say it is. The energy sweeping the country is of a people (at least those I have seen at rallies) who are aching to get to the voting booth. It is more than about the MDC ( and probably the party leader's greed).

    So if these people see participating in flawed and illegal elections as "futile" then why are they doing it?

    I can understand why some people, especially those who have never had the chance to really understand what is going on and are desperate for change, would believe all the nonsensical promises from MDC leaders. When nonsense is all you hear, what else is there to believe!

    "I would say let's vote and if the people feel strongly aggrieved at the outcome I am sure POVO is wise enough to take action. I know collective action is difficult but if the itch is strong enough we will see a revolution. Again quitters never win, the only danger is dampening the robust spirit that is flowing in the land (at least among the people I have seen at rallies of both the zany party and the people's party).

    By participating in the flawed and illegal elections you are giving the process credibility and legitimacy. Why is that so difficult for you to understand? But, of course, you probably understand that but only pretend not to understand for the sake of deceiving the naïve and gullible public to participate.

    Zanu PF is desperate to make sure the idea of people boycotting the elections much less demand of the international election observers to declare them null and void is stifled at all cost. Zanu PF's electoral victory will be a Pyrrhic one if the elections are declared null and void!

    Albert Einstein said insanity "is doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result." By claiming that they are no quitters, is certainly one way to justify their insanity!

    You can participate in these flawed elections on Monday but by high noon you will be looking your usual stupid self as you once again admit that Zanu PF rigged the elections! Or, if you are a Zanu PF double, will be celebrating with ED for a job well done.

    However, do not pop the champagne before the international election observers are done, I really do not see any of them accept this electoral farce as a free, fair and credible election. Just because MDC leaders are corrupt and incompetent it will be very presumptuous of Zanu PF to believe the international community is corrupt and incompetent too!

    These elections are not free, fair and credible that is a fact no one, not even Zanu PF, can deny. The genie is out of the bottle, there is no putting it back!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Mnangagwa said in the event that Zanu-PF loses he will smoothly hand over power to the victorious party.

    Well it is nice to hear that but only the very naïve with the memory of a duck will believe him. If he is so hot at upholding the law then why is he rigging these elections. When he announced that nomination day for these elections would be 14 June 2018 he must have known that ZEC had not yet produce a clean and verified voters' roll at least one month before nomination day. We are 7 days before voting day and still there is no credible, clean and verified voters' roll. Only the naïve duck would believe these elections can be free, fair and credible with not verified voters' roll especially when one remembers the blatant vote rigging that took place in 2013!

    President Mnangagwa has no qualms about handing over power because he knows he is not losing these elections.

    The only relevant question President Mnangagwa must answer is: Why have you promised to hold free and fair elections but have done nothing to make this possible?

    Does he really believe there can ever be free, fair and credible elections when many who should vote are not on the voters' roll, are denied the vote by making sure they do not know which polling station they are supposed to use, Zanu PF supporters cast multiple votes, etc.?

    ReplyDelete