Sunday, 4 December 2016

Zim's destiny depends on course we take: opposition unity or implement reform. By Wilbert Mukori

There is not even one thinking Zimbabwean out there who would disagree that the country is in economic ruins with unemployment a nauseating 90% and 76% of our people now living in abject poverty and denied their freedoms, human rights, human dignity and hope. There is no question about how caused the economic ruins – 36 years of gross mismanagement, rampant corruption and lawlessness by the corrupt and tyrannical Zanu PF one-party cum one-man dictatorship. The public debate is now focused on what should be done to get the nation out of this mess?

There two competing schools of thought as to what the forward should be:

a)     There are those who are saying we should expend all our time, energy and treasure on uniting the country’s opposition; making sure the electorate register to vote and then go out to vote en masse coming voting day. The argument here is that Zanu PF will be defeated if we do not divide the opposition vote and people vote in such big numbers that rigging the vote is impossible.

b)     The second school of thought is arguing that we should expend all our time, energy, treasure, sweat, blood - everything on getting the democratic reforms designed to dismantle Zanu PF’s vote rigging juggernaut so that the next elections are free, fair and credible because only free and fair elections will deliver a compete government. If not a competent government, then at least one with some common sense.

There are several reasons why uniting the opposition and contesting the elections with no reforms is doomed to fail and here is a few of these reasons:

There is no quality in the opposition and quantity is a poor substitute for quality.

It has been long in coming but it is now beginning to dawn on many people that quality matters, that we are in this mess because the corrupt and incompetent opposition let us down. Both Morgan Tsvangirai and Joice Mujuru are corrupt and incompetent, their political track records speaks volumes, and per se they will never accomplish anything of substance.

Tsvangirai had his best chance to implement the democratic reforms during the GNU; he failed to get even one reform implemented. Not even one! To get out of this mess the country must implement the democratic reforms a.s.a.p. and it is naïve to trust Tsvangirai to do so if he was to lead the next government.

“Now, Mrs Mujuru’s genes, her DNA is 100% Zanu PF. We all know that had she not been expelled from Zanu PF, she would still be a vice president aspiring to inherit that coveted throne” wrote Rejoice Ngwenya in Zimeye.

Of course, Rejoice is right, Mujuru is Zanu PF in all but name. If she was elected back into office, she will be looking at carrying on with the corruption and mismanagement where she left off when she was booted out of Zanu PF in 2014. 

A united opposition of Tsvangirai, Mujuru plus many others equally corrupt and incompetent will increase the head count, quantity, but they will still be corrupt and incompetent and therefore will not deliver the political and economic changes the nation needs. It will take quality leadership to get the economy back on track and not just a change of name of who is president.

If you can rig the vote, politics in more than a game of numbers.

Mugabe has always wanted Zimbabwe to be a one-party state and from the word go he has set his mind to establish and retain the de facto one-party cum one-man dictatorship that has misruled this nation these last 36 years and landing us in this mess. As the national economy started to falter and with it his popularity with the people; Mugabe has resorted to all manner of dirty tricks to rig the vote including the use of wanton violence. Mugabe has turned vote rigging into an art, numbers count for nothing. 

In the March 2008 elections Tsvangirai got 73% of the votes, by Mugabe's own admission, but after six weeks of recounting the 5 million votes, Mugabe's ZEC whittled down 73% to 47%.

In the presidential run-off that followed Mugabe launched a military style operation "Mavhotera paps!" (Whom did you vote for!). He deployed Police, Army, CIO and war veterans to punish the people for having voted for MDC in the March vote. The country witnessed its worst ever election violence and over 500 people were murdered. Mugabe got 98% of the vote and ZEC took less than a day to count and declare the result!

In the 2013 elections, the nation was spared the wanton violence but only because Mugabe had devised a very sophisticated vote rigging scheme. He paid an Israeli company NIKUV a princely sum of US$ 10 million to corrupt the voters roll so that nearly one million voters (Mugabe’s winning margin that year was just over one million) were denied the vote because their details were posted in some other constituency than the one they expected. 

Two days before the elections the number of polling station was increased from 2 000 to 9 000 and hooded Zanu PF youths were seen on Youtube videos being bussed from one polling station to the next casting multiple votes. 

The law of the land says the voters roll must released one month, at least, before voting day; Mugabe refused to do so. If he had done so, then people whose details were posted in wrong constituencies would have had the chance to have this corrected, for example. In fact to this day, Mugabe still refuse to release the 2013 voters roll; he knows that it is the smoking gun of the blatant vote rigging that took place that year.

Zanu PF’s vote rigging juggernaut is a well-funded machine.

$15 billions of diamond revenue was looted, again by Mugabe’s own admission, in the period 2010 to 2016. He made the surprise admission in February and to date no one has been arrested and Finance Minister has also confirmed that government is still collected revenue from one out of the expected six million carat diamond output; proof that the looting in still going on. It is no secret that some of the looted billions are now being used to fund Zanu PF’s vote rigging schemes.

Vote rigging is the elephant in the room, opposition unity is only the mouse

Many Zimbabweans have developed the knack for ignoring the elephant in the room squeezing everyone else out and talk of the mouse instead. For decades, Mugabe has denied that corruption was undermining national development and the economy. He blamed the drought and sanctions instead allowing corruption to grow and spread. What nation of earth can sustain the haemorrhaging of $15 billions much less one with Zimbabwe’s GDP of $14 billions.

The people of Zimbabwe should have stood firm against Mugabe’s vote rigging shenanigans soon after independence; we did not, allowing the tyrant to develop and perfect his vote rigging dirty tricks. During the GNU, the country had its best chance ever to implement the reforms and end the Zanu PF dictatorship; Tsvangirai wasted that chance.

The task of stopping Zanu PF rigging elections has become progressively more and more difficult because the regime has had all these years to entrench itself into power. But just as the cancerous corruption has grown and spread and now poses a serious threat to the economic life of the nation and therefore cannot be ignored any more. So too is the vote rigging; Zimbabwe’s economic meltdown is socially and politically unsustainable and political reform is the key to unlock economic reform. This nation cannot afford yet another rigged elections and thus delay economic recovery.

Why we need the NTA to implement the democratic reforms

Tsvangirai and other opposition leaders in the Nation Electoral Reform Agenda (NERA) have been calling on Zanu PF to implement electoral reforms, without even bothering to discuss the merits of these reforms, it is naïve to expect Zanu PF to president over reforms designed to dismantle the party’s political power base. Senior Zanu PF leaders like Professor Jonathan Moyo and VP Mnangagwa have already public stated that the party will never do any such thing.

There are rumours that Tsvangirai is negotiating with Zanu PF to enter yet another GNU. Since the primary task of the new GNU would be to implement democratic reforms leading to free and fair elections, the same task the two parties failed to get even one reform implemented last time. The two parties failed to get even one reforms implemented for various selfish reasons, those reasons are still there today. It would be naïve to trust Mnangagwa and/or Tsvangirai to implement all the reforms thoroughly and expeditiously.   

The task of implementing the democratic reforms must be given others who played very little or no part in the failed GNU or the Zanu PF dictatorship of those last 36 years. A National Transition Authority (NTA) is one such political body that could formed and tasked to implement the reforms.

The last GNU was a product of the political crisis born out of the wanton violence and vote rigging of the 2008 elections, we do not need to have a repeat of another rigged elections of social upheaval in the country to justify the NTA. The present economic situation is socially and politically unsustainable and we should embrace change now without inflicting any more suffering on our people much less shed another drop of blood in street protests or political violence.

Taking part in 2013 elections with no reforms was foolish it will be folly to do so again

SADC leaders warned Tsvangirai not to take part in the 2013 elections with no reforms implemented. Tsvangirai thought he had the numbers on his side to overwhelm any vote rigging by Mugabe. He was wrong as we know and the nation has paid dearly for it. Taking part in any future elections without implementing any reforms is sheer folly.

Demanding free, fair and credible elections is NOT asking for too much

It was the Greeks who, 2500 years ago, came up with democracy as a just and stable system of government, the ante-dote to autocracy and tyranny, in which everyone had a meaningful say in the governance of the country. We know that the de facto Zanu PF dictatorship has not worked, we do not need someone else to tell that or that we need change. They are those who are pretending not to know what constitute free, fair and credible elections and are asking us to sweep all evidence of vote rigging by this regime under the carpet. We must ignore them and demand, not in a shy way but firmly, the implementation of all democratic reforms to ensure the next elections are free, fair and credible.

Mugabe and his Zanu PF thugs portray themselves as the nation’s liberation heroes when all they did was remove the white colonial oppressors with the new oppressors – themselves. It is right and proper that we look the tyrant in the eye and demand free and fair elections as our birth right, that is not asking too much, even of a seasoned corrupt and murderous tyrant!


  1. Cde Chinx says he has fallen on hard times as he cannot work to fend for his large family.

    "My family is in poverty right now. Because of this sickness I'm failing to work yet I'm supposed to be the breadwinner. I have six children here in Chitungwiza and four in Norton plus my two wives, myself and my mother. All these people need to be fed," said Dickson "Cde Chinx" Chingaira, in an interview with The Sunday Mail at his home.

    What war veterans like Chinx have failed to accept is that the Zanu PF dictatorship was doomed to fail because no corrupt and tyrannical regime has ever brought prosperity. War veterans like Chinx helped President Mugabe create this tyrannical regime. It is a great pity that some war veterans still continue to this day to prop up the dictatorship.

  2. The failure by the country's opposition parties to come up with a definitive position on any of the burning issues is itself proof of just how incompetent they are. Tsvangirai and his MDC-T have dithered back and forth on what reforms they wanted, whether the party will boycott the elections if no reform are implemented, etc.

    Some people have concluding from this that MDC-T still have no idea what the reforms are and they have a point.

    There is no doubt in my mind that Zanu PF has taken advantage of the confusion in the opposition camp to do nothing about implement even some token reforms much less consider giving in to the idea of the NTA. The confusion in the opposition camp meant there was no pressure on the regime to change. Tyrannical regimes like Mugabe's are not the type to give up power because it makes sense - they will have to feel sustained increasing pressure.

    The way things are going, it is almost certain that Zanu PF will never implement any meaningful reforms, the opposition will never form and opposition coalitions strong enough to hold not that it will matter, The opposition will present a token fight demanding reforms and still take part in the elections as happen in the past. With no reform Zanu PF will rig the elections and the country will be in the chaotic situation it is in right now!

    This is just a nightmare, the chaotic path we are so desirous to avoid is the one we are set to travel!

  3. “It is right and proper that we look the tyrant in the eye and demand free and fair elections as our birth right, that is not asking too much, even of a seasoned corrupt and murderous tyrant!” That is a tall order my brother.

    There are millions of Zimbabweans out there whose lives are a hell-on-earth today because they have been out of work for donkey years now and they now live in abject poverty, for example. Some of them know that President Mugabe and his cronies have been looting the nation’s resources big time and their looting is a big factor in the country’s economic meltdown and their poverty. But let me tell you this my brother, few of these people will have the courage to say it in their own head that they want free, fair and credible elections much less “look the tyrant in the eye” and say it!

    Before independence blacks were third class citizens. The whites were the first class citizens enjoying all the freedoms and human rights; the Indians and coloureds were second class enjoying some of the rights and blacks were the exploited and oppressed with even fewer freedoms and rights. Most blacks accepted their position but grudgingly!

    After independence Mugabe and his ruling elite became the first class citizens with same rights and privileges to exploit and oppress as the whites; the rest of the war veterans became the second class with some freedoms and rights but not all and the masses remained third class citizens still oppressed and exploited. The majority of the people, again accepted their third class status but instead of doing so grudgingly they resigned themselves to their fate which means the fire to fight for justice was gone.

    Before independence the economic conditions of the blacks were far better than it is today and yet still the blacks were restless for change because the fire of rebellion was burning strong. They have tolerated see the country go to the dogs after independence because the flame of rebellion had long been extinguished.

    We need to reignite the fire to allow most of our people to view themselves as worthy human beings entitled to the same freedoms and human rights as everyone else. Then and only then will they have the courage to look the tyrant in the face and demand their freedoms and human rights.

    Of course, there is no one out there who does not know that Zanu PF has been rigging elections. They also know that until all the democratic reforms are implemented there will never be free and fair elections. But because the fire demanding justice has gone out a long time ago and have accepted they will never enjoy the same freedoms and rights as the ruling elite they instinctively settle for whatever the ruling elite give them – elections in which Zanu PF still retain the privileges of rigging the vote!

    Most of these people are convinced Mugabe and Zanu PF will never give up their tyrannical dictatorial powers and therefore it is utterly pointless even trying. The GNU presented the scenario when this could have been done but still these sceptics refuse to acknowledge this. There is no one more blind than he who close their eyes and refuse to see.