Saturday 25 December 2021

"Army plays a decisive role in politics" - rubbish, it played no role in MDC's failure to implement reform W Mukori

 

“It is beyond any iota of doubt in Zimbabwe that the institution of the military plays a decisive factor in the politics of the country,” reported The Independent.

“Numerous "clever" politicians have attempted to suggest and insinuate about something they call "security sector reform" or "reform of the military" yet history is laden with case innuendoes of where the military in Zimbabwe has decided the trajectory of politics, to a point of reforming the behaviour of political actors.

“It is foolhardy for one to resist to note this overt truth, a truth that is so "loud to see" and "big to hear", if ever English words can be played around in such a fashion, just to prove how this institution plays a central role in the politics of the country.”

 

These sweeping statements founded on conjecture and ignorance and not on fact and reality.

 

There is nothing to suggest Zimbabwe’s security services; the Police, Army, CIO and Prison Services; were doomed to be the corrupt and partisan institution they are today. If it was not for the corrupting influence of Zanu PF they would be carrying out their duties and Zimbabwe would be a healthy and functioning democratic country.

 

Robert Mugabe did not have a single drop of democratic blood in his veins; he was a control freak tyrant who wanted absolute power and was pretty ruthless in insuring he got what he wanted. He surrounded himself with dimwits like the late Simon Muzenda, Joice Mujuru and Emmerson Mnangagwa. Mugabe’s regime was a Sultan’s harem full of subservient eunuchs and wives.

 

“Mose murivakadzi vaMugabe!” (You are all Mugabe’s harem wives!) Ms Margaret Dongo reprimanded her fellow Zanu PF Ministers, MPs, etc. in sheer exasperation at their failure to stand-up to Mugabe even when the situation demanded it, such as the 1983 to 1987 Gukurahundi massacre. Of course, she was right and, more significantly, her fellow Zanu PF leaders themselves and the nation at large knew she had hit the nail on the head!

 

It comes as no surprise that the same tyrannical and control freak, Robert Mugabe, would have stopped at nothing to groom and mould the country’s security services to serve his one-party state agenda at the expense of the nation’s democratic agenda. If Mugabe had brow beaten his fellow political leaders into submission; what more the Police Officers and the soldiers, obliged to take his commands as their Commander-In-Chief, no questions asked!

 

“The Zvinavashe Doctrine, pronounced in early 2000 (which begins with words, "We want to make it abundantly clear that the military will not salute anyone without liberation credentials") shows a decisive inclination in values and prove the unbridled fact that the military in Zimbabwe at least thus far, is, and remains, the single most important institution insofar as the statecraft of the country is concerned,” argued The Independent.

 

The Independent is referring to the then Zimbabwe Defence Forces chief Vitalis Zvinavashe’s threat the Army will not salute Morgan Tsvangirai if won the elections. The threat was repeated that year and on several other occasions since by many senior officers in the Army, Police, etc.

 

History will show that by 2000 the top brass in the country’s security services were already brainwashed into believing the de facto one-party state, formally adopted by the signing of the 1987 Unity Accord between PF Zapu and Zanu PF, saved the country’s best interests. The multi-party democracy, symbolised by the emergence and election of the opposition parties, was not in the nation’s interest.

 

If the Zanu PF government and Commander-In-Chief, Robert Mugabe, had not encouraged the treasonous Zvinavashe doctrine; the regime’s failure to condemn it spoke volumes on the matter.

 

Robert Mugabe founded the Joint Operation Command (JOC) comprising the top brass in the four security branches plus a few select individuals from Zanu PF headed by Mugabe himself with Emmerson Mnangagwa as his assistant. The primary purpose of JOC was to help Mugabe impose the de facto one-party dictatorship.

 

When Mugabe and Zanu PF were routed in the March 2008 vote; Mnangagwa and JOC stopped ZEC declaring the results. The Junta spend the next six weeks recounting 5 million votes, whittling down Tsvangirai’s 73% votes, according to Mugabe’s Freudian slip, to 47% - enough to force the run-off. The Junta came to its own in implementing the military style Operation “Mavhotera ani?” (Whom did you vote for?)

 

The Junta punished the voters for rejecting Zanu PF and Mugabe in the March vote; hundreds of thousands were harassed, beaten and/or raped and millions were internally displaced using the war veterans and Zanu PF militia. The heavy-duty stuff of abducting a murdering people was carried out by personal from the Army, Police, CIO and Prison Services. Over 500 innocent people were murdered in cold blood in that operation.

 

Until 2008, the security services’ involvement in the rigging of elections and other political activities had been confined to the Zvinavashe doctrine and other clandestine work. All caution was thrown to the wind during Operation Mavhotera ani marking the 2008 as a watershed election. The top brass in the Army, Police, CIO and Prison Services must have known their active involvement in Operation Mavhotera ani, was a point of no return. They had lost all pretences of being independent, apolitical and committed to multi-party democratic values.

 

It was in the post 2008 election era that the security services branches’ involvement in diamond mining and other looting activities increased significantly. Mugabe was no doubt rewarding his JOC junta partners for helping him and Zanu PF stay in power and increasing their stake in the dictatorship.

 

When the Junta carried out the political coup in 2008 to wrestle power from MDC, Operation Mavhotera ani was a political coup, none of them ever imagined that SADC and AU would refuse to recognise Zanu PF as the legitimate government, punishment for the blatant cheating and wanton violence. Mugabe was forced to sign the 2008 Global Political Agreement, agreeing to the implementation of the raft of democratic reforms designed to dismantle the dictatorship.

 

Fortunately for Mugabe, Morgan Tsvangirai and his MDC friends, who were tasked to implement the reforms turned out to be corrupt, incompetent and utterly useless. They failed to implement even one reform in five years of the GNU. Not even one!

 

Zanu PF emerged from the GNU with all its dictatorial powers untouched include the party’s undemocratic control over the Army, Police, etc. and the carte blanche powers to rig elections. The party realised that it would avoid the punishment for rigging the elections as long as the opposition participated in the elections. The party has since given away a few gravy-train seats to entice the opposition to participate.

 

By participating in the flawed elections opposition are giving vote rigging Zanu PF legitimacy.

 

"It is beyond any iota of doubt in Zimbabwe that the institution of the military plays a decisive factor in the politics of the country."


This is not one iota of evidence to show the military, or any of the other three security services branches, have played any role in MDC’s failure to implement reforms during the GNU and/or MDC’s stubborn insistence in participating in flawed elections to give Zanu PF legitimacy. Not one iota!

 

The November 2017 military coup should not be taken as proof of the military influence in Zimbabwe politics because the coup would have never happened if the G40 faction had not made it clear it would ouster the liberation war generation. The overwhelming majority in JOC were liberation war generation and it is no wonder the coup was code-named “Operation Restore Legacy!”

 

The November 2017 coup was reportedly to “remove criminals around the President” responsible for the economic meltdown, announced the coup spokesperson; proof the coup plotters are aware the army are not the only players in Zimbabwe politics. Indeed, there is increasing talk of yet another coup and/or street protests to force change because the November 2017 coup has failed to deliver hoped for economic recovery.

 

Zimbabwe’s de facto one party dictatorship has benefited the few ruling elite at the expense of the overwhelming majority forced to live in abject poverty. The system is economically, socially, morally and politically unsustainable. The country needs meaningful political change.

 

One way sure way to delivery orderly political change is implementing the democratic reforms agreed in the 2008 GPA. The Army did not resist the implementation of the reforms back then and there is nothing to suggest it will do so now!

11 comments:

  1. @ P Mphoko

    “The Constitution of Zimbabwe, states very clearly that ZAPU and ZANU liberated Zimbabwe. Comrades Joshua Nkomo brought ZAPU and led his supporters into the Unity and Robert Mugabe respectively brought ZANU and led his supporters into the Unity. Not that only ZANU brought its supporters, into the Unity as suggested by the prevailing situation.

    There is no one at the moment in Cabinet or Politburo who was present at the formation of the JMC in Mbeya, as those revolutionary principles were laid down. There is no one in Cabinet or Politburo who was present when ZIPA, the second Military Unity between ZPRA and ZANLA, was formed in 1975, and there is no one in Cabinet or Politburo who was present at the formation of the Patriotic Front in 1976.

    It is a fact that ZANU did not unite with itself but with ZAPU. The 22 December 1987 Unity Accord between ZAPU and ZANU was signed for a different purpose related to post Independence killings. The Unity Between ZAPU and ZANU was achieved long back when the Patriotic Front was formed in 1976. All negotiations were done collectively as a United Patriotic Front of Zimbabwe. Since its formation, the Patriotic Front of Zimbabwe united the people of Zimbabwe. However, that Unity was destroyed when the co-leader Robert Mugabe, pulled out of the Unity citing that he had been accused by people like Muzorewa, Matimba and others for giving the leadership of the people of Zimbabwe to the Ndebeles.”

    In the beginning, it was “One man, one vote!” putting the ordinary people at the centre of the fight for independence. Sadly, for Zimbabwe both Zanu and Zapu very quickly forgot about the ordinary people as the two circled each other like bulls at the dip-tank. Even now, with benefit of hindsight, both Zanu and Zapu member are fighting each other over power, oblivious of the fact the fight for independence was about freedom and liberty for all and not just the leaders!

    The sooner the nation can implement the democratic reforms and end the Zanu PF dictatorship, restore the freedoms and rights of every Zimbabwean and reinstate the principle that no one is above the law; the sooner the nation can finally put the 41 nightmare years of Zanu PF tyranny behind us.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "They want to throttle us, make sure that they advance the consolidation of authoritarianism, tyranny by banning the existence of the MDC Alliance as an alternative."

    However, Chamisa added: "We have stood our ground, we have managed to resist this persecution and the fact that we are still standing is actually something we must give kudos to the people of Zimbabwe for continuing to support us, to believe in us.

    "This is why we have continued to give an alternative platform to Zimbabweans so that we give them hope.

    Zimbabwe is a Banana Republic that has failed to hold free, fair and credible elections, that is a historic fact. What is also a historic fact is that the country has had many golden opportunities, notably during the 2008 to 2013 GNU, to implement the democratic reforms and end the Zanu PF dictatorship. Nelson Chamisa and his MDC friends have not only wasted the many golden opportunities to end the dictatorship but are also the ones keeping the regime in power by participating in flawed elections giving it legitimacy.

    "The most critical issue in our view is that SADC continued to face is the stability and peace in the region, which is a critical issue," said Chamisa.

    "This is why the (SADC) Organ Troika is such an important mechanism to be able to ensure that we have credible elections, good governance, and stability.

    "There cannot be economic development without political stability."

    Well, that is rich! Since it is MDC that has insisted in participating in elections with no reforms to stop Zanu PF rigging the elections against SADC leaders’ advice to implement the reforms before elections!

    What the people of Zimbabwe expect from the SADC leaders is to once again look Chamisa and company in the eyes as they did in June 2013 and tell them they should not participate in elections without first implementing the reforms.

    ReplyDelete
  3. THE presidency has announced that Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Tutu has died.

    In a statement on Sunday, minister in the presidency Mondli Gungubele said President Cyril Ramaphosa “expresses, on behalf of all South Africans, his profound sadness at the passing today, Sunday December 26, of Archbishop Emeritus Desmond Mpilo Tutu”.

    poster

    Archbishop Tutu, the last surviving South African laureate of the Nobel Peace Prize, passed away in Cape Town at the age of 90.

    Rest in peace! You have touched many lives in SA, in Africa and beyond. Thank you very much!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Electoral theft has become a cancerous practice that negates the will of the people, he noted. He said lethargy in the Southern African Development Community (Sadc) with regards to reversing this anomaly continues to affect electoral outcomes.

    "It is doubtful that there has ever been a fully democratic election in Zimbabwe since (and including) 1980. However, it is abundantly clear that every single election since 2000 has been disputed on good grounds, never tested adequately in the courts, resulted in international opprobrium, and has resulted in Zimbabwe being the most politically polarised country in Africa," Mandaza added.

    "It is also evident that virtually every form of electoral irregularity that can be described has been present in Zimbabwean elections since 2000 and, even when the opposition wins an election, as in 2008, there is little appetite in the region to compel Zanu-PF to cede political power, this in spite of the fact that Sadc and the AU were in full knowledge that Zanu-PF has not won any of the elections since 2000."

    There is a lot of good things SADC could and should have done to help Zimbabwe end the de facto one-party, Zanu PF, dictatorship. Still, we must admit that SADC’s 2008 Global Political Agreement (GPA) did offer us a way out of this hell-hole. SADC arm-twisted Robert Mugabe and Zanu PF to agree to the implementation of a raft of democratic reforms designed to dismantle the dictatorship and restore the individual freedoms and rights including the right to a meaningful say in the governance of the country.

    The task of implementing the reforms were entrusted to Morgan Tsvangirai and his MDC friends. Sadly, MDC failed to implement even one reform in five years of the GNU. Not even one reform!

    Credit where credit is due, SADC leaders nagged MDC leader to implement reforms but were ignored. SADC leaders, literally, begged MDC leaders not to participate in elections without reforms but, once again, their pleading fall on deaf ears. It was none other than Dr Ibbo Mandaza himself who witnessed and reported on the June 2013 SADC leaders begging.

    SADC leaders were right; the way out of the hell-hole for Zimbabwe is to implement the democratic reforms, there is other way out. By participating in flawed elections MDC is only giving Zanu PF legitimacy.

    ReplyDelete
  5. They said unless this anomaly was ironed out, it will be very difficult for the party to maintain its hitherto unassailable dominance in the province, which it considers its bastion.

    "There is a serious outcry over the way the elections were conducted and the clear evidence of rigging which renders the results not a reflection of the wishes of the people of Mash Central," the letter, signed off by Zimbabwe National Liberation War Veterans Association provincial chairman Sam Parirenyatwa, reads.

    "This will most likely pose serious challenges for the new administration to effectively unite the and run the province most effectively, a challenge the outgoing administration has perennially encountered. More so as we edge towards 2023 with our five million vote vision," it reads.

    Whatever voting irregularities the war veterans are complaining about, they are nothing compared to the down right criminal activities we have seen visited on to the opposition by Zanu PF operatives including war veterans themselves! What is really of great concern here is: if Zanu PF thugs are rigging the party’s elections how much worse will they do to the national elections. It is absolute mad that the nation is once again being dragged into the 2023 elections without no reforms in place all because of MDC greediness!

    ReplyDelete
  6. @ Dr Mavaza

    “Zimbabwe looks to the overseer called (ZAAC)Zimbabwe Anti Corruption Commission. The nation has not understood how ZAAC works. ZAAC is a body which investigates and arrests suspects in corruption cases. Those arrested by ZAAC are not corrupt but they are suspected to be corrupt. This means when they go to trial they may be convicted or indeed acquitted. There are indicators which assists ZAAC in investigations. Understanding those indicators is a prerequisite towards determining reasons why achievements fell short, establish ways and means of strengthening anti-corruption efforts, render the outcomes more impactful and visible and consequently meet expectations of the general public and the international community.

    The anti‐corruption successes of ZAAC is not seen in the number of convictions. ZAAC does not judge neither does it prosecute it only arrests. The presence of ZAAC has encouraged the establishment of strong, centralized anti‐corruption agencies in companies and government departments across the country. We must realise that there is no criteria for assessing and explaining ZAAC’s performance. We must establish the minimum political, legal, and socio‐economic conditions for effective governance. When these conditions are in place, success is possible.”

    When Mnangagwa got into power following the November 2017 military coup, he promised zero tolerance on corruption. Four years latter he has all but failed to stamp out corruption.

    ZACC boasted a weeks ago that it was set to recover US$700 million in looted property and wealth. The truth is this is but a drop in the ocean. In 2016 Robert Mugabe said the country was being “swindled out of US$ 15 billion in diamonds alone” He never arrested one swindler nor recover one dollar. We know the looting continued because the then Minister of Finance Patrick Chinamasa told parliament in 2017 that government was only receiving 1/6 of the expected diamond revenue.

    Last July Reserve Bank Governor, Dr John Mangudya, said Zimbabwe was losing US$1.2 billion to gold smugglers every year.

    So, Zimbabwe may well have lost US$100 billion to corruption in the last 20 years alone! In the last four years all ZACC has recovered is US$ 700 million or less than 1%! Only an apologist like Mavaza would consider this a success on ZACC’s part!

    ReplyDelete


  7. The truth however, is this is just for show and is rarely enforced. How then can we use the beautiful Constitution to fight for our liberties?

    The first step is to set up a pirate radio stations. If the despot shuts it down, sue in court. No judge can rule against the country's rights enshrined in a Constitution - the law of the land.

    Mugabe "dictated" the 2013 constitution as Paul Mangwana, the Zanu PF co-chair person on the parliamentary committee that drafted the document, boasted soon after the constitution was approved in the March 2013 referendum. Some Zanu PF cronies made a big song and dance about how much they disliked the new constitution - a rouse to help galvanise the opposition support of the constitution!

    It is sad that even now with all the evidence of serious shortcoming of the 2013 constitution, there are some people who still think it is a democratic constitution. The reason is these people are incapable of comprehending anything beyond the superficial!

    ReplyDelete
  8. When asked if he will not regret his utterances, Moyo said, "The word never exists for a reason in the English language. As for joining the MDC, certainly for me it's a never; and I think it's the same for most former and indeed current Zanu PF members; former MDC members will join Zanu PF in droves; but the flipside is a pie in the sky!"

    It was USA ambassador to Zimbabwe 2004 to 2007, Chris Dell, who said Morgan Tsvangirai “was a flawed and indecisive character who will be an albatross round the nation’s neck if he ever got into power!” Dell could have said the same thing about the entire MDC leadership; the party has turned out to be breathtakingly corrupt and incompetent. The party’s failure to implement even one reform during the GNU has put them beyond the pale.

    Professor Jonathan Moyo is right, MDC members joining Zanu PF is one thing; who would want to join a party whose reputation is damaged beyond repair!

    ReplyDelete
  9. The chief secretary to the Office of the President and Cabinet Misheck Sibanda announced the decision Sunday, saying the awards would be given to people who deserved this "special recognition".

    "Government intends to award deserving Zimbabwean citizens with the Robert Gabriel Mugabe Commendation Award for Service in Human Capital Development," he said in a statement.

    "The individuals should be luminaries who have distinguished themselves through outstanding transformative services in human capital development that have opened up and achieved growth in new economic sectors while ensuring inclusivity."

    Mnangagwa and company were super confident the “Zimbabwe is open for business” mantra was going to take off like a rocket. It was a lead balloon that never even lifted off! The regime has since given up all hope in stamping out corruptions, holding free and fair elections, the lawlessness, etc.; all the bad things that had earned the country its pariah state status.

    As long as Zimbabwe remains a pariah state there is no hope of any meaningful economic recovery. The regime is now coming up with all manner of meaningless policies and awards, anything to draw the people’s attention away from the worsening economic meltdown and tragic human suffering.

    ReplyDelete
  10. The matter is about Ngomahuru Hospital, a Provincial and National Hospital at large located in Masvingo. There had been stories early last year concerning the issue of lack of water and electricity that lead to bathing of patients in rivers that had crocodiles but the matter was unresolved how so ever since patients are no longer bathing at all.

    Ngomahuru has over 200+ psychiatric patients and 200+ workers who depend on water and electricity at large for the running of day to day activities. Electricity has been gone for over a week to 2 weeks now, not to mention periods in between the year that the same issue has been happening with no urgent action taken by ZESA and ZINWA mainly due to ZESA as well. This means that patients do not bath withing those periods and they have less water to drink and maintain hygiene especially during Covid 19.

    So government is upgrading the Masvingo to Harare Road and it makes a big song and dance about it, presenting it as proof the country is on course to achieve its middle income, vision 2030, status. And yet the nationwide decay and rot that started soon after independence dragging the nation out of the middle-income status to the present impoverished nation status continues unchecked!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Jealous Mawarire posted this on his Twitter account.
    “Dewa ndovave panyanga saka munhu wese position, position”, get ready G40 is overtaking #2023Chatsva!

    Mnangagwa and company justified the 2017 military coup on the grounds they were removing the criminals around Mugabe who were causing the economic meltdown. It is now four years since the coup and the economy is in a worse state now than it was before the coup – proof the real criminals remain, according to the G40 members.

    MDC have proven to be utterly useless and ineffective and so G40 are filling the vacuum! G40 have two more things that MDC factions do not have – wealth and inside information of how Zanu PF operate. There are many people in Zanu PF right now who will switch sides the minute they realise Mnangagwa and company losing control.

    ReplyDelete